17 September 2015

Chinese troops intrude in Ladakh: a coincidence?

By Claude Arpi
16 Sep , 2015

Was it a coincidence?

Just the day before the new stand-off between the Indian and Chinese defence forces in Ladakh started, a senior member of the Chinese Central Military Commission visited the region.

The Indo-Tibetan Border Police apparently objected to the construction of the structure and, with the help of the Army, stopped the PLA.

Let us look at the facts.

As it already happened before the visit of Premier Li Keqiang to India in April/May 2013 and also as President Xi Jinping arrived in Ahmedabad in September 2014, the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) intruded on India’s territory.

The face-off is currently happening in Burtse area, a few miles east of Daulat Beg Oldie (DBO), where the 2013 confrontation occurred.

According to The Times of India, “the bone of contention is a surveillance structure being erected by the PLA very close to the Line of Actual Control (LAC).”

The Indo-Tibetan Border Police apparently objected to the construction of the structure and, with the help of the Army, stopped the PLA.
Subsequently, the PLA called for reinforcements, followed by a massing of more Indian forces in the area.

The Times of India said: “The two forces are still locked in an eyeball-to-eyeball confrontation and efforts are being made to defuse the situation.”

The Coincidence

On September 9 and 10, a member of the all-powerful Central Military Commission visited Ngari Prefecture, which borders Ladakh, in Western Tibet. General Zhang Yang was in Tibet to ‘celebrate’ the 50th anniversary of the creation of the Tibetan Autonomous Region.

At the end of the main function held in Lhasa, the ‘Central’ delegation divided itself into different groups. As mentioned in a post, Yu Zhengsheng went to Shigatse and visited the Tashilhunpo.

Vice-Premier Liu Yandong went to Shannan (Lhoka) Prefecture, while Jampa Phuntsok ‘inspected’ Nagchu. Another ‘sub-delegation’ led by Du Qinglin, Vice-chairman of the CPPCC, went to Nyingchi.
…during his visit to Ngari, General Zhang Yang and his delegation “made a special trip to lay a wreath on the revolutionary martyrs’ cemetery.” Which martyrs? 1962 again?

General Zhang Yang headed for a two-day tour of Ngari Prefecture. He went to convey the ‘loving care’ and the ‘deep feeling’ of the CPC Central Committee, the State Council, and the Military Commission to the ‘cadres and masses of all nationalities’.

Note that ‘of all nationalities’, just means ‘Tibetans’.

Like his colleagues, General Zhang brought along a banner carrying President Xi’s words, ‘Strengthen National Unity and Construct a Beautiful Tibet’.

Zhang was accompanied by Lt. Gen. Xu Yong, commander of the Tibet Military District.

Speaking at the main function in Lhasa, Lt Gen. Xu Yong had, a day earlier, declared that after 50 years of vicissitudes, with the region’s rapid economic development and social progress, the living standards of the masses’ have markedly improved and social stability has overall been sustained: “During these 50 years in the same boat, the troops stationed in Tibet and police staff always depended on the Party’s to write the bloody battles to defend Tibet, carve a new chapter the history of Tibet.”

What does General Xu refer to, when he speaks of ‘bloody battles’? It is not clear. The 1962 conflict with India?

Xu lavishly praised his boss, CMC’s Chairman Xi: “All the troops stationed in Tibet and police officers must resolutely obey the Central Military Commission and Chairman Xi command; conscientiously implement the Sixth Tibet Work Forum’s spirit; vigorously carry forward the heritage of the ‘Old Tibet Spirit’ and faithfully fulfill our mission of responsibility,… and make new and greater contributions for the great prosperity of the motherland and border stability.”

Nothing new!

Also in the delegation, was Wang Yongjun of the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection (CCDI). A year ago,WantChinaTimes had reported that the CCDI’s boss, Wang Qishan had started ‘parachuting’ CCDI officials into key posts around China in order to strengthen the party’s anti-graft campaign and bring new blood to certain regions.

In January, 2014, Wang Yongjun, formerly deputy dean of the China Discipline Inspection and Supervision Institute was transferred to head the Tibet regional branch of the dreaded (by the corrupts) CCDI.


Was the ‘political’ general informed that the PLA was planning to build a structure in an area considered by India to be within her territory?

The Political Commissar of the Tibet Armed Police Corps, Xiao Tang was also in attendance in Ngari.

After the customary photo sessions with the ‘cadres and the masses’, (i.e. herders, farmers, toilers, etc.), the General who also heads the PLA’s Political Department, stressed “the need to thoroughly study and implement the spirit of the important speech Xi Jinping, in particular, his speech at the Sixth Work Forum and implement the good advices given by Yu Zhengsheng during the 50th anniversary function.”

He concluded, “seize the opportunity, work hard and continue to strive.”

This is the usual stuff.

But during his visit to Ngari, General Zhang Yang and his delegation “made a special trip to lay a wreath on the revolutionary martyrs’ cemetery.”

Which martyrs? 1962 again?

And perhaps more importantly, one line in the local press mentions that Zhang ‘visited the troops’.

Was the ‘political’ general informed that the PLA was planning to build a structure in an area considered by India to be within her territory?

If Zhang was not informed, the PLA has a serious problem of command.

If he was informed, it is a serious issue for India.

PS: By the way, where was Lt. Gen. Peng Yong, the commander of the Xinjiang Military District, who looks after Ngari area?

Can a Yong (Xu) replace a Yong (Peng)?
© Copyright 2015 Indian Defence Review

No comments: