December 1, 2014
Pentagon buildingWho should President Obama tap to lead the Pentagon?Agence France-Presse – Getty Images
The resignation of Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel is being seen as a sign of President Obama’s desire to shake up his national security team and acknowledge that the country is back at war. Given the onslaught of global crises, what skills should Obama look for in a Pentagon chief?
Obama will need a Pentagon chief who can fight grinding counterinsurgency campaigns in two theaters under the financial pressures of a congressional sequester.
Lawrence J. Korb
Obama Is Looking for a Loyalist
LAWRENCE J. KORB, CENTER FOR AMERICAN PROGRESS
A new secretary must be comfortable with the dominant role of this White House in the decision-making process, and must support the president despite opposition.
Janine Davidson
Someone Comfortable With Military and Civilians
JANINE DAVIDSON, COUNCIL ON FOREIGN RELATIONS
Having a strong, competent professional at the helm in the Pentagon will make zero difference if Obama is not willing to consider uncomfortable advice.
Kiron Skinner
A Thoughtful Secretary With a Doctrine
KIRON SKINNER, FORMER DEFENSE DEPARTMENT OFFICIAL
Given Obama’s commitment to centralizing power, placing someone who knows how to generate ideas at the helm of the Pentagon is the most immediate challenge.
The President Needs a Secretary of War
John Nagl
John Nagl, a retired Army officer who served in the first two Iraq wars, is the headmaster of The Haverford School and the author of “Knife Fights: A Memoir of Modern War in Theory and Practice.”
NOVEMBER 30, 2014
Chuck Hagel is a good man. He turned down a college deferment offered by his draft board to serve as an enlisted man in Vietnam, where he was wounded. He recovered, enjoying a successful business career and two terms representing Nebraska in the U.S. Senate; John McCain still calls him “Sarge.”
Obama will need a Pentagon chief who can fight grinding counterinsurgency campaigns in two theaters under the financial pressures of a congressional sequester.
For all his accomplishments, however, Hagel was not a success as the first former enlisted man to lead the Defense Department. The problem was not so much who Hagel was as who he wasn’t. Brought on to manage a downsizing Pentagon and a diminishing combat role in Afghanistan, Hagel was never a member of President Obama’s close inner circle, nor a man intended to serve as secretary of war.
When the Islamic State took advantage of a premature American withdrawal from Iraq to seize territory the size of the state of Maryland, the president had an Iraq war of his very own to deal with. This disaster put the planned troop withdrawal from Afghanistan very much in question. Sadly, the Pentagon management skills the president needs for the final two years of his administration now look much like what he needed during the first two: fighting grinding counterinsurgency campaigns in two theaters, this time under the financial pressures of a congressional sequester.
Fortunately, two veterans of those early years in the Obama Pentagon are available to serve. The physicist Ashton Carter ran the Pentagon’s weapons acquisitions and logistics programs before becoming Leon Panetta’s deputy secretary of defense, the chief management officer of the world’s biggest organization. John McHugh, a Republican congressman from New York, has been Obama’s only secretary of the Army, ably managing the nation’s largest armed service. Both have earned the president’s trust; either would serve ably and well in a role the president thought he no longer needed: secretary of war.
Obama Is Simply Looking for a Loyal Pentagon Chief
Lawrence J. Korb
Lawrence J. Korb, a former assistant secretary of defense in the Reagan administration, is a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress.
NOVEMBER 30, 2014
Being secretary of defense is one of the most difficult and demanding jobs in the U.S. government. The secretary functions as the deputy commander in chief of U.S. armed forces, is a member of the National Security Council, develops a defense budget that shapes the military and accounts for 40 percent of the world’s military expenditures, and manages an organization of three million people.
A new secretary must be comfortable with the dominant role of this White House in the decision-making process.
The ideal candidate will have served in the military. Political and managerial experience are important, but in the short time the new secretary will be in office, he or she will have only limited ability to reshape the defense budget or reform the broken acquisition process. Finally, he or she must share the president’s worldview about how to deal with the national security threats to this country.
Ironically, Chuck Hagel had more of these attributes than any of his predecessors. He was a decorated Vietnam veteran who was wounded in combat, served two terms as a U.S. senator and was a successful manager in both the public and private sectors. On paper he was an ideal fit for the job. Hagel was let go because, like his immediate predecessors Leon Panetta and Robert Gates, he did not work well with those in Obama’s inner circle, who have taken increasing control over national security policy.
Hagel was let go not because the national security challenges the nation faces are very different from when he was confirmed less than two years ago, but because the president needed to demonstrate that he was taking action to shake up what many perceive as an incoherent national security strategy, especially toward the challenges of ISIS in Iraq and Syria, and Putin’s invasion of Ukraine.
A new secretary must first and foremost be comfortable with the dominant role of the White House in the decision-making process, and must forcefully support the president’s approach to foreign policy challenges, both publicly and privately, despite opposition from the military, the Republicans and much of the foreign policy establishment. Obama is looking for a loyalist, not an iconoclast.
Obama Needs Someone in the Pentagon Comfortable With Military and Civilians
Janine Davidson
Janine Davidson, a senior fellow for defense policy at the Council on Foreign Relations, is a former U.S. Air Force officer and was deputy assistant secretary of defense for plans from 2009 to 2012.