By BARBARA OPALL-ROME
Sep. 20, 2014
Aftermath: A Palestinian family walks past the remains of a building destroyed in fighting between Hamas militants and Israel in Shejaiya, in Gaza. The Israeli military says the next conflict will be more complex. (ROBERTO SCHMIDT/ / AFP/Getty Images)
TEL AVIV — Israeli military leaders are assessing how lessons from Gaza could apply to war planning in Lebanon, Syria and other potential theaters.
But officers charged with future war planning are already nostalgic for the relative simplicity of Israel’s summer of combat in the Gaza Strip. Although challenging to battle well-armed enemies deeply embedded among innocent civilians, Israel still had the relative luxury of targeting so-called centers of gravity in its 50-day war in the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip.
But in a fractured region in continuous flux, those centers of gravity are giving way to pockets of gravity with no single address, officers here say.
In this new Middle East of breakaway insurgencies and blurred borders, Israel can no longer direct its “bowling ball” — as one officer here described it — against a single strongman or central government.
“When it was nation against nation, it was relatively simple,” said Brig. Gen. Oren Avman, head of Israeli Army training and doctrine. “If you selected the right ball and threw it in the right way, you could effectively strike all those pins supporting the enemy’s center of gravity.”
But in a region with multiple pockets of gravity, Israeli planners are mulling how to decapitate only immediate threats without empowering others that continue to sprout.
In the Army, they’ve already started to replace metaphorical bowling for billiards, where artful strategy and geometrically calculated tactics is more effective than brute force.
“You have a table with many balls and many pockets and you’re holding a big stick. If this stick is not efficient and it causes you to put in the black ball — let’s call it civilians — you lose legitimacy,” Avman said.
“But if you scratch with the white ball, you’re squandering your capabilities.”
Officers here said the operational concept was demonstrated in maneuvering ground war in Gaza, but will prove inordinately more challenging in the Lebanese or Syrian theater.
“We have to use this big stick carefully and with extreme accuracy, because enemies are hiding among civilians all the time,” Avman said.
“And that’s just Gaza.”
Against threats to the north, those metaphorical billiard balls must be targeted in ways that won’t strengthen the spectrum of forces operating in the same domain, Avman said.
“When we look around in Lebanon, they have an army supported by the US. But there is another huge army [Hezbollah] backed by Iran operating by guerrilla methods in villages and tunnels.
“If you look at Syria, after more than 200,000 dead, they’re still killing each other. And now this so-called Islamic State joined the party and we have al-Qaida extremists meters from our border fence.”